The Murder of Pearl Bryan (part two)

Two dental students, two trials, one missing head. Ohio and Kentucky fight over the case, Cincinnati turns it into a sideshow, and a gallows morning comes down to a single sentence one man refuses to say.

Where to Listen

They drained a reservoir and dragged the Ohio River. They dug up a sandbar and chased a stage conjurer’s “clue.” Pearl Bryan’s head was never found.

In part two, we piece together Pearl’s last four days in Cincinnati: a hotel register signed with her sister’s name, an argument outside a music company, and a sarsaparilla in a saloon’s back room. Then comes the circus.

There are lemonade stands at the murder scene, a shooting gallery offering a five-cent cigar to anyone who shoots Scott Jackson’s effigy, a witness bribery scheme that falls apart on the stand, and two defenses built on epilepsy and hypnosis.

It all leads to March 20, 1897, when a governor’s offer, a five-minute decision and one man’s silence settle everything. And at the end, a ritual that still happens at a small Indiana grave: pennies, left heads up.

To see more about this case, as well as the sources used to create this episode, visit our Blog Here.

Find Crime Clueless socials, website, and more here

Thank you for listening – we are grateful for you!

Support Crime Clueless – Buy Me A Coffee