In a respectable Massachusetts household in 1892, two people were hacked to death in broad daylight, and nobody in the house heard a thing.
This episode traces the Borden family from Andrew’s rise from nothing to a $10-million-in-today’s-money fortune he refused to spend, through the locked doors, the pigeon massacre, and the property dispute that split the household in two. Then: the morning of August 4th, the two-hour gap between the murders, the botched police investigation, the burnt dress, and the trial that put actual human skulls in front of a jury.
Lizzie Borden walked free. Whether that was justice or a masterclass in reasonable doubt is still argued over more than 130 years later — and we give you the evidence to decide for yourself, including how you can go and spend the night in the room where it happened.
Topics Included
- Andrew Borden’s fortune, and his refusal to spend a cent of it on his own family
- The 1891 house robbery and the household’s growing paranoia and distrust
- The pigeon massacre and the Ferry Street property dispute that split the family in two
- The morning of August 4, 1892, and the unexplained two-hour gap between the murders
- The Fall River police’s botched investigation and their first, wrongful suspect
- Lizzie’s shifting testimony, the burnt dress, and the poison purchase ruled inadmissible
- The 1893 trial, the skulls brought into court, and the fast acquittal
- What happened to Lizzie, Emma and Bridget Sullivan afterwards — and what you can actually do at the house today
Resources and Further Reading
- Lizzie Borden — Wikipedia
- Lizzie Borden House — Wikipedia
- Was Lizzie Borden Guilty? — Britannica
- Famous Trials: Lizzie Borden
- Famous Trials: The Inquest
- The Lizzie Borden Society chronology
- How Lizzie Borden Got Away With Murder — Smithsonian
- The Forgotten Borden: Who Was Emma Borden? — Lizzie-Borden.com
- I Slept in the Murder Room — Fodor’s